Permalink for Comment #1379653891 by mgolia6

, comment by mgolia6
mgolia6 First off, Megan, thanks for weathering the storm and sharing your experience. Todd they J’s in the dryer in a shoe bag on delicate and you should be fine (are they 4’s)…I digress.

Loved your perspective. Something about anything but the ordinary when it comes to weather that solidifies an experience for me. Glad everyone is safe, but I do love getting spooked by a good storm.

On the review, I have only had a chance to catch the Chalkdust and, this one is for @GREGHAPPE (watch the free second set opener on YouTube here:
.

People might not be giving you the details but from my perspective this was about 20 minutes of very little, call it Chalkdust Tortured!!

So I went looking for some corroboration of the sub par quality of 7/18 and I stumbled upon set 2 opener of 7/19, Chalkdust Torture and maybe I was projecting but the staleness seemed to be pervasive tonight as well. Slow tempo’d but not like intentional, just kind of off. Trey was playing so many notes and starting and stopping so many musical thoughts that were disjointed with one another. If he found a lick he liked he didn’t stick with it for long. After this piecemeal jaunt through the first jam, the band reprises the chorus before trying to delve deeper and the consensus from this listeners ears is that they should have cut their losses and gone right into Oblivion instead of heading into “oblivion” because it just never went anywhere.

A few noteworthy observations: Mike’s bass seemed super low tonight, like way lower than normal. There was a point when Trey stopped playing for a moment and it felt like Page was going to step up and lead, but that was short lived and would have been week received. It wasn’t until late in the game that Trey started employing some of his sound rig effects and not that I want purely effects laden Trey but he could have gone early with the effects and maybe that would have salvaged the song. Trey was playing a lot of notes, almost meandering through passages looking for something to inspire and it was almost as if he was following click bait, jumping from thought to thought.

Anyhoo, still in agreement with Jmart, nobody’s perfect and we are all allowed to have an off night (or two as it seems). I guess god pulled the ripcord tonight with the weather cancellation mid second set.


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2024  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode